Gary Sheffield Rookie Cards

Do you know that the most expensive Gary Sheffield Baseball Rookie Card (Gary Sheffield Card Rookie Rare 15 Of Only 16 Made 89 Rookie Card) was sold on eBay in 03/2025 for $16000.00 while the cheapest Rookie Card (Topps 1989 Future Star Rookie Gary Sheffield #343 Milwaukee Brewers MLB Card) changed hands for only $0.01 in 03/2026? The month with the most cards sold (180) was April 2026 with an average selling price of $3.36 for a Baseball Card of Gary Sheffield. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in August 2014 with $50.00 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $0.79 was October 2011. In average, a Rookie Card from Gary Sheffield is valued at $3.39.

Affiliate disclosure: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network

Here's a list of Baseball Rookie Cards of Gary Sheffield that are currently for sale on eBay and some other online shops.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	1989 Fleer Rookie Card {{{ Gary Sheffield }}} #196 ~+Bonus Card~L@@K	$3.95
	1989 Fleer #196 Gary Sheffield RC Rookie Baseball Card 0302L	$2.89
	1989 Fleer Gary Sheffield Baseball Rookie Card (RC) #196 Brewers IF VG O/C	$71.30
	1989 Score Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Card #625 Gary Sheffield Rookie RC MVP HOF	$1.73
	1990 Topps #718 Gary Sheffield Brewers / Yankees All-Star Rookie Cup ?Card?	$3.00
	Gary Sheffield 1989 Donruss Rated Rookie #31 Milwaukee Brewers MLB Baseball Card	$4.74
	Gary Sheffield 1989 Donruss Rookie Card #31 MLB Milwaukee Brewers	$1.95
	Gary Sheffield 1989 Upper Deck #13 Rookie Baseball Card - CGC MINT+ 9.5	$24.99
	GARY SHEFFIELD RATED ROOKIE #31 DONRUSS BASEBALL 1989 ROOKIE CARD	$1.04
	SCORE 1989 Score Gary Sheffield Rookie #625 Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Card	$1.00
	Topps 1989 Gary Sheffield #718 Milwaukee Brewers All-Star Rookie Baseball Card	$8.99
	Upper Deck 1989 Star Rookie Gary Sheffield #13 Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Card	$12.00

To give you a bigger picture, here are some more Baseball Rookie Cards of Gary Sheffield that were sold recently on eBay. In total, we scanned 4205 sales to create the statistics about price trends and current value of Gary Sheffield Baseball Rookie Cards shown on top of this page.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	1989 Boman #142 Gary Sheffield Rookie Card (RC) - Milwaukee Brewers	$1.99
	1989 Bowman Gary Sheffield Baseball Rookie Card RC #142 Milwaukee Brewers ?⭐️⚾️	$1.00
	1989 Bowman Gary Sheffield rookie baseball card	$19.99
	1989 Score Gary Sheffield Rookie #625 Base Set Milwaukee Brewers Baseball Card	$5.32
	1989 Upper Deck Gary Sheffield Rookie Card #13 – Brewers HOF – Clean NM	$15.99
	Donruss 1989 Gary Sheffield #31 Rated Rookie Brewers Beckett Graded 8 Card	$10.00